The Rafu Shimpo - L.A. Japanese Daily News Advertise with Rafu
 Subscribe Advertise Japanese
Coming Soon!
Welcome
Home
News
Sports
Community
Features
Calendar
Columnists
About Us
Submit An Article
Meet The Staff
Links
Opinion
Photo Gallery
Through The Fire
Japanese Textbook Revision and Historical Amnesia
By Ryan Masaaki Yokota
Monday, May 7, 2007

Recently a number of decisions and statements have occurred with ter­rible ramifications for the presenta­tion of Japanese history in Japan and abroad. Most recently, for example, the Japanese Education Ministry has removed references in government-ap­proved middle and high school text­books to the forced civilian suicides that occurred during the Battle of Okinawa. Concurrent with this move has been a statement by Prime Min­ister Shinzo Abe in which he denied that the “comfort women” stations maintained by the Japanese Imperial Army had been “coerced.” Though he later recanted this statement and apologized after receiving a great deal of international pressure, his state­ment follows over a decade of work in which references to the “comfort women” have been systematically erased from these same government approved history textbooks. All told, these recent moves on the part of the Japanese government represent a trend toward “historical amnesia” on the part of the Japanese state that has served to censor and limit Japanese popular understanding of the realities of World War II.   
Yokota
Ryan Masaaki Yokota

The situation in Okinawa, for ex­ample, has been well documented by those survivors of the Battle of Oki­nawa. As former governor of Okinawa Masahide Ota recalls, civilians were given hand grenades by the Japanese Army and told to kill themselves rather than be taken captive. When such civilians attempted to surrender and leave the caves in which they had taken refuge, they were often shot by Japanese soldiers as deserters. Inci­dents such as these mentioned by sur­vivors of the war like Oda are among the crueler aspects of Japanese history that have been recently deleted from Japanese textbooks.      

As for the “comfort women” issue, the most important statement from the Japanese government on this issue came in the 1993 Kono Statement, in which then-Chief Cabinet Secretary Yohei Kono reported that government findings had confirmed that the gov­ernment was involved in ordering the procurement of “comfort women” for use by the military, stating that:

“The Government study has re­vealed that in many cases they were recruited against their own will, through coaxing, coercion, etc., and that, at times, administrative/military personnel directly took partin the recruitments. They lived in misery at comfort stations under a coercive atmosphere.”  

This acknowledgement came as a great victory to the survivors of the “comfort women” system, many of whom had lived in shame and extreme hardships since the end of the war, and had overcome great reluctance to tell their story and force the Japanese gov­ernment to accept their responsibility in this terrible episode in history. That Prime Minister Abe and his cabinet have even questioned such historical realities makes a mockery of these women’s experiences and does a dis­service to the cause of history.          

All told, the recent controversies suggest that the right-wing trend in the current Japanese administration, in keeping with Prime Minister Abe’s vision of a “beautiful country” free of war guilt and geared towards the future, seeks to obscure historical realities regarding these incredibly important issues. Indeed controversies regarding historical controversies in Japan are not new. One need only ref­erence the right-wing Japanese Society for Textbook Reform to see that many people have been seeking to remove references to such terrible aspects of Japanese history for some time. The main difference, however, is that the current Japanese education ministry has systematically implemented many aspects of this organization’s view­point by deleting or limiting references to the forced suicides of Okinawa, the “comfort women,” and other is­sues such as the Rape of Nanking or Unit 731.

Despite these moves, however, there is a groundswell of popular movement in Japan that has sought to contest this distorted view of history. One important organization in this regard is the Violence Against Women in War–Network Japan (VAWW-Net Ja­pan) (http://www1.jca.apc.org/vaww-net-japan*), which was instrumental in publicizing the impact of the war on the comfort women through its 2000 Women’s International Military War Crimes Tribunal on Japan’s Military Sexual Slavery. This organization was instrumental in organizing activities aimed at urging the Japanese admin­istration to stand by the 1993 Kono statement. In fact, for those interested in learning more about this history, there is now a historical museum in the Waseda area of Tokyo called the Women’s Active Museum on and Peace (www.wam-peace.org*) that focuses on recording and promoting awareness of the “comfort women” issue. Additionally, in Kawagoe in Saitama, there is another recently opened museum called the Chukiren Memorial Peace Museum that has served to document records from Japanese soldiers who have testified on their complicity in war crimes dur­ing the occupation of China. Also, in regards to the truth of the Battle of Okinawa, visitors today can visit the Okinawa Prefectural Peace Museum (www.peace-museum.pref.okinawa.jp*) or the Himeyuri Peace Museum (www.himeyuri.or.jp) to find out more about the experiences of Okinawan civilians during the war. Thus, despite the rightward trend of the Japanese administration, at the grassroots and local level there continues to be significant popular awareness of the need to oppose the erasure of histori­cal truth.       

Yet, this issue of Japan’s wartime responsibility is not something that must remain solely a matter of discus­sion in Japan alone. Members of the Nikkei community should and must also add their voices to this matter as a means of applying international pressure on the Japanese government to acknowledge the faults of the past. I am encouraged by the recent push by U.House Representative Mike Honda to pass a resolution calling on Japan to unequivocally recognize its responsibility for the “comfort women” during World War II. These moves among others are positive steps towards developing an international historical consensus on the issues at the heart of that terrible war.

  • English language page avail­able.

 

________________

Ryan Masaaki Yokota is a Yonsei/Nisei of Japanese and Okinawan descent born and raised in Southern California. He is currently a graduate student in the Ph.D. program in Japanese History at the University of Chicago who writes from Yokohama, Japan. The opinions expressed in this column are not necessarily those of The Rafu Shimpo.

More Columns...
   

Wanted!

 
Home | Contact Us | Subscribe | Advertise
COPYRIGHT © 2008 LOS ANGELES NEWS PUBLISHING CO. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED